My reaction to the Mayoral Environmental Educational Forum (and some of what I wish had been said)

The Mayoral Environmental Educational Forum, which you can listen to on YouTube, offered an opportunity to hear Mayor Bass and Councilmember Raman discuss some of the environmental issues facing Los Angeles. This is what stood out to me.

Environmental leadership
While it is true, as Mayor Bass said, that the City of LA has been seen as a leader on environmental issues, this is not because of Bass’s work, but rather because of her predecessors’, which she did not clarify.  Councilmember Raman is right that we have fallen behind in the past four years.

Raman discussed the dismantling of programs and offices—including decarbonization of City buildings, biodiversity, the Office of the Petroleum Administrator (where the report for the Vista Hermosa motion that we have worked on appears to be stuck), Planning’s environmental justice unit, and staffing to implement Measure HLA, off the top of my head—in addition to the continued underfunding of staffing to care for trees.

I do, however, appreciate Bass’s framing of environmental, economic, and health justice as interconnected.

Climate and heat
Regarding the threat to the Climate Emergency Mobilization Office, I was surprised to hear that it had been tasked with developing the Mayor’s Climate Action Plan. But I will let former CEMO director Marta Segura’s own words speak for themselves.

I think both Bass and Raman missed an opportunity to promote heat pumps instead of conventional ACs, the fact that electric appliances are far more efficient than gas appliances (and much cooler), and cooling strategies such as bioswales and greywater systems (but was pleased to hear Raman mention trees).

Wildfire resilience
Regarding fires, I would have liked to hear Bass talk about the risks of type conversion and invasive species that can come with brush clearance, and would direct her to these resources about brush clearance on our website.

Measure HLA
Bass addressed Measure HLA, an often-avoided topic. While she didn’t sound like a fan (“whether or not we are going to be able to go full bore…we obviously are going to move forward, it was a ballot measure that was passed”), she said that it had required planning and that there are other things we can do, saying that she was a big fan of barriers.

Raman supports HLA but did not mention it. Given the connections among transportation, public health, climate, and the use of public space, I would have liked to hear more about how both candidates see the measure fitting into their broader environmental goals.

Water
Raman appeared to be better versed on stormwater capture than Bass, consistent with what we saw in the Mayor’s Climate Action Plan. She pointed out that right now most of our stormwater goes to the ocean and that we need to do more to capture it at both the household and street level. While she did not mention native plants, she did say we need to think about landscaping and more water-efficient planting.
It would have been really fun to hear one of the candidates mention their support of our efforts to ban new installations of artificial turf (which, by the way, also gets crazy hot), but we heard nary a word.

Energy and affordability
Bass’s message seems to be that electrification is expensive, implying that utility bills increased for Jordan Downs residents when they went all electric. (Update—we did look into this. While electricity per unit of energy is more expensive than gas—listen to this podcast to learn about the climate-crisis related costs added into your electricity, but not your gas, bill, to understand a reason why—heat pumps and induction cooktops are many times more efficient than gas appliances, so folks typically save money by going all-electric in the long-term. But apparently the residents of Jordan Downs—a public housing development—hadn't been paying a separate utility bill, and hadn't previously had central air. And when they first went all-electric, they didn't have heat pumps. So, for several reasons, they suffered a bit of a shock.) Raman reminded listeners that renewable energy investments are cheaper than fossil fuel ones and said that she did not move forward on the new-building decarbonization motion until she was assured that electrification would not add to the cost. Granted, this is a complex subject, in part because rates are not stagnant.

Raman had some interesting ideas regarding energy—empowering the ratepayer advocate, installing smart meters, and establishing a task force focused on affordability among them. While she mentioned making sure that appliances are as efficient as possible, it would have been great to hear her say that electric appliances are much more efficient than gas ones.

Other observations
Bass’s default response to a few questions was housing, consistent with her focus. Land use, of course, is deeply connected to climate, affordability, and health. While I was excited to hear her talk about the adaptive reuse of office buildings that has taken place under her administration, I would have liked to hear more about how housing is connected to sustainability.

Raman also did not mention that Bass waived the new-building electrification ordinance that resulted from the motion Raman had introduced, or that Bass did not reappoint Raman to the South Coast AQMD board following their disagreement about managing emissions at the port.

What distinguishes them
The final question was what distinguishes the two candidates. Bass pointed to her record, while Raman emphasized her sense of urgency and focus.


–Lisa Hart, executive director

 

Updated October 29, 2026